I thought for a minute. “That first poker night at his dad’s.”
Errrr! America made a horrendous noise with her throat. “When he realized he wasn’t good enough for you, which was the moment he saw you. Drink!”
“Aw!” Harmony said, holding her hand to her chest.
I picked up a small plastic cup and squeezed its contents into my mouth. Yum. I wasn’t going to mind losing at all.
“Next question!” America said. “What is his favorite thing about you?”
“My cooking.”
Errrrr! America made the noise again. “Drink!”
“You suck at this game,” Kara said, clearly amused.
“Maybe I’m doing it on purpose? These are good!” I said, popping another shot into my mouth.
“Travis’s answer? Your laugh.”
“Wow,” I said, surprised. “That’s kind of endearing.”
“What is his favorite part of your body?”
“My eyes.”
“Ding, ding, ding! Correct!”
Harmony and Kara clapped, I bowed my head. “Thank you, thank you. Now drink, bitches.”
They all laughed, and popped their shots.
America turned a page and read the next question. “When does Travis want to have kids?”
“Oh,” I blew through my lips. “In seven . . . eight years?”
“A year after graduation.”
Kara and Harmony made the same face, their mouths forming “oh.”
“I’ll drink,” I said. “But he and I will have to talk about that one some more.”
America shook her head. “This is a prewedding game, Abby. You should be much better at this.”
“Shut up. Continue.”
Kara pointed. “Technically she can’t shut up and continue.”
“Shut up,” American and I said in unison.
“Next question!” America said. “What do you think Travis’s favorite moment of your relationship was?”
“The night he won the bet and I moved in?”
“Correct again!” America said.
“This is so sweet. I can’t take it,” Harmony said.
“Drink! Next question,” I said, smiling.
“What is one thing Travis said he’ll never forget that you’ve said to him?”
“Wow. I have no idea.”
Kara leaned in. “Just guess.”
“The first time I said I loved him?”
America narrowed her eyes, thinking. “Technically, you’re wrong. He said it was the time you told Parker you loved Travis!” America burst into laughter, and so did the rest of us. “Drink!”
America turned another page. “What is the one item Travis can’t live without?”
“His motorcycle.”
“Correct!”
“Where was your first date?”
“Technically it was the Pizza Shack.”
“Correct!” America said again.
“Ask her something more difficult, or we’re going to get hammered,” Kara said, throwing back another shot.
“Hmmm . . .” America said, thumbing through the pages. “Oh, here we go. What do you think Abby’s favorite thing about you is?”
“What kind of question is that?” I asked. They watched me expectantly. “Um . . . my favorite thing about him is the way he always touches me when we sit together, but I bet he said his tats.”
“Damn it!” America said. “Correct!” They drank, and I clapped to celebrate my small victory.
“One more,” America said. “What does Travis think your favorite present from him is?”
I paused for a few seconds. “That’s easy. The scrapbook he got me for Valentine’s Day this year. Now, drink!”
Everyone laughed, and even though it was their turn, I shared the last shot with them.
Harmony wiped her mouth with a napkin, and helped me to collect the empty cups and place them on the tray. “What’s the plan now, Mare?”
America fidgeted, clearly excited about what she was about to say. “We hit the clubs, that’s what.”
I shook my head. “No way. We talked about this.”
America stuck out her lip.
“Don’t,” I said. “I’m here to renew my vows, not to get a divorce. Think of something else.”
“Why doesn’t he trust you?” America said, her voice very closely resembling a whine.
“If I really wanted to go, I would go. I just respect my husband, and I would rather get along than sit in a smoky club with lights that give me a headache. It would just make him wonder what went on, and I’d rather not go there. It’s worked so far.”
“I respect Shepley. I still go to clubs without him.”
“No, you don’t.”
“Only because I haven’t wanted to, yet. Tonight, I do.”
“Well, I don’t.”
America’s brows pulled together. “Fine. Plan B. Poker night?”
“Very funny.”
Harmony’s face lit up. “I saw a flyer for movie night tonight at Honeymoon Beach! They bring a screen right on the water.”
America made a face. “Boring.”
“No, I think it sounds fun. When does it start?”
Harmony checked her watch, and then her face fell, deflated. “In fifteen minutes.”
“We can make it!” I said, grabbing my purse. “Check please!”