“Fin,” I said, trying to keep the contempt from my voice. “What a surprise.”
“I know,” she said, finally releasing me. She wiped her cheek. “I didn’t warn you. But I knew you’d say not to come. It’s been ten months, Ellie. I couldn’t give you one more day of space. You’re my sister.”
“I’ve been calling you like you asked.”
“I know,” she said, glancing at Marco. “But it’s not enough. You’re my best friend.” Her eyes danced between Tyler and me. “What? What aren’t you telling me?”
Tyler looked at me, and my mind raced for a believable lie.
“We’re uh … we’re moving in together,” I said.
Finley and Tyler shot me identical expressions.
“We were going to try to move my things before the New Year. It’s just a really bad time for our first visit.”
“Oh,” Finley said. She looked a bit lost, and then a grin spread across her face. “Well, congratulations, you two!” She hugged both of us, and Tyler choked when Finley squeezed his neck into her shoulder. “That is so exciting. Our parents can’t wait to meet you,” she said, pointing at him with her glasses. “They’d love to see your new place. I would love to see your new place!” She clasped her hands together. “In Estes?”
Tyler looked at me with his mouth hanging open, unsure how to respond.
“Yes, it’s in Estes Park,” I said. “He has an apartment across town from mine.”
“Can we go now?” Finley asked.
“Fin…”
“I just came to Colorado to see you. I literally have nothing else going on.”
“…great. That’s great,” I said with wide eyes and a forced smile. I looked to Tyler. “Um … uh … honey, I guess they can follow us to my apartment? You can just drop me off. I know you have a lot of things to do.”
He mouthed honey with a disgusted look on his face behind Finley. I shot him an expectant smile that surely made me look like a lunatic.
“Sure … honey,” he said. “Are you familiar with this area?” he asked Marco.
“I have navigation,” he said with a proud smile.
“We’ll meet you off Peña Boulevard at the Avis rental place, then you can follow us from there.”
“Are you guys hungry?” Finley asked. “You must be.”
“No,” I said, shaking my head quickly. “Not really.”
“Oh. Okay, then … we’ll meet you at Avis in ten minutes.”
“Perfect,” I said, smiling at them until they walked out the door.
Tyler and I didn’t speak until we made it to the truck and he slid into the driver seat and shut the door.
“This is awful!” I cried.
“This is fucking great!” he said with a wide smile.
I glared at him. “They’re coming to my apartment. I’m stuck with Fin for an entire evening. She’ll find out about Sterling by dinnertime. I’m fucked.”
Tyler wrinkled his nose. “I don’t understand your strategy, Ellie. You haven’t seen your sister in almost a year to avoid her finding out something that may or may not make her never want to see you again.”
“Exactly.”
“If you never see her again, what does it matter?”
“At least she won’t hate me.”
Tyler drove us to Avis, and I waved at Finley from behind the passenger side window of the truck. They followed us north on the toll road toward Estes Park.
I sighed for the fourth time in ten minutes.
“Ellie…” Tyler began.
“I have less than an hour and a half to figure this out. What are you doing?” I screeched.
“What?” he cried.
“You’re speeding! I need time to think of a way to keep her out of my apartment!”
Tyler eased back on the accelerator, looking annoyed. “What if you tell her it’s being fumigated?”
“Then she’ll go to your apartment.”
“So?”
“She’ll expect me to come, too.”
“Okay, then you get car sick on the way to Estes.”
“I like it, but it’s a temporary fix to a permanent problem.”
Tyler sighed. “Maybe … maybe you should just tell her.”
“Are you out of your mind? Do you want Finley to hate me?”
“If it were me—” He hesitated. “I would be more upset that you kept it from me. She’ll get over it if you’re honest with her.”
“No,” I said, shaking my head. “You don’t know Fin like I do. She holds grudges, and Sterling …”
“Is a whiney little cunt nugget.”
I closed my eyes. “Don’t say that to her.”
When we pulled into the parking lot of the MountainEar, my heart began to pound in my chest, and my palms were slick with sweat.
“You’re sure you don’t want me to come in?”
“Just long enough to follow me into the bathroom and…”
Marco knocked on Tyler’s window. He looked at me and then pressed the button, waiting until it rolled all the way down.
“Hey, Ellie’s not feeling great. I think she’s a little car sick.”
“My sister doesn’t get car sick,” Finley said from behind Marco. “Why are we at her work? I thought we were going to her apartment?”